"Gazelles" by Alfred Baccache. Copyright status unknown. Courtesy New York Public Library.

Religion

The Syrian community of New York City was mainly made up of four Christian sects, Maronites, Melkites, Orthodox, and a few Protestants, but it is likely that some Druse and Muslims were also present; if so, they had blended into the community well. The first Arabic-speaking priest arrived at the end of 1889 and others soon followed.
Loyalty along sectarian lines was the rule but did not preclude cross-religious marriages or business relationships. Many of the early associations were sectarian in nature, but there were also literary and self-improvement societies that welcomed all. Arabic newspapers tended to have a sectarian bent, but tried to appeal to a wide audience. Political differences often reflected sectarian divides but political sympathies could transcend sect.  

The community was small, and people inevitably got to know those of other religions, and many were ecumenical in outlook, reflected in the poetry and literature produced in the colony.
Letter from "The Catholic Syrians" to New York's Catholic Archbishop Corrigan requesting an Arabic-speaking priest be brought to New York.  Undated, but probably November 1889.
Letter from "The Catholic Syrians" to New York's Catholic Archbishop Corrigan requesting an Arabic-speaking priest be brought to New York. Undated, but probably November 1889.
The first Arabic-speaking priest assigned to the burgeoning Syrian colony was Khalil Beshewate, a Melkite, who presided over his first service on Christmas Eve, 1889. The Maronite priest, Peter Korkemas, arrived shortly after. Accompanying Korkemas was Joseph Yazbek, who became the first Maronite priest to be ordained in America.  Orthodox Archmandrite Raphael Hawaweeny arrived in New York from Russia in 1895. 
At first the different congregations met in American churches, but once the priests arrived, each congregation wanted its own chapel. They formed benevolent associations to raise money to convert a commercial space on Washington Street to a chapel. All succeeded except the Melkites, who continued to meet in the basement of St. Peter's Catholic Church on Barclay Street until 1914. The Maronites fitted out a chapel on the second floor of 81 Washington Street in 1893, the Orthodox did the same at 77 Washington in 1895, and the Protestants began to meet upstairs at 95 Washington with members of the congregation serving as lay ministers.
 
Since they were the only Arabic-speaking priests in the United States, their responsibilities included ministering to Syrians living in other parts of the country. They traveled around for up to six months a year, performing the liturgy and presiding over weddings and baptisms in farflung Syrian communities. These communities would delay their rites until the Syrian priest arrived. The priests also used these trips to raise money to build permanent churches in New York City, but this was not possible until the New York Syrian community became prosperous enough to purchase buidings in Brooklyn.

Tenuous evidence for a small Muslim population was the establishment in 1912 of a Muslim "prayer hall" on Greenwich Street, one block east of Washington Street. Nothing more is known about this hall or the Muslims who might have used it.

Orthodox Archmandrite (later Saint) Raphael Hawaweeny, 1898.
Orthodox Archmandrite (later Saint) Raphael Hawaweeny, 1898.
Orthodox Archbishop Platon, and Bishops Raphael and Alexander together in New Jersey, ca. 1910.
Orthodox Archbishop Platon, and Bishops Raphael and Alexander together in New Jersey, ca. 1910.
Letter from Maronite priest Joseph Yazbek to New York's Archbishop Corrigan, 3 April 1893.
Letter from Maronite priest Joseph Yazbek to New York's Archbishop Corrigan, 3 April 1893.
The priest Peter Korkemas arrived in New York to minister to American Maronites in 1890.
The priest Peter Korkemas arrived in New York to minister to American Maronites in 1890.